Image retrieved from Canva
Introduction
I have been learning how assessments are essential to the learning process. Assessment is a crucial component of teaching, as it measures the achievement of educational objectives. The assessment results influence various decisions, including grading, student placement, promotion, identifying areas for instructional improvement, curriculum development, and sometimes resource allocation. "Are we teaching what we think we are teaching?" "Are students learning what they are supposed to be learning?" "Is there a way to teach the subject better, thereby promoting better learning? (Edutopia, 2008) In the rapidly changing landscape of education, assessments stand out as a critical component in measuring student progress and effectiveness of teaching, as stated by Stiggins (2005), "As the mission of schools changes from ranking students to ensuring that all learn to specified standards. The purpose and form of assessments must change as well.” Traditional assessments have been tools for assessing how well students grasp academic material. However, as educational practices and technologies advance, so do the methods of assessing student learning. Today, educators face new challenges and opportunities as they transition from conventional grading systems to more sophisticated technology-enhanced evaluations. Understanding these aspects is crucial for educators striving to enhance their teaching practices and better support their students’ learning journeys.
Assessments: Their Importance and Evolution
Assessments have long been a foundation of education, serving as the primary method to evaluate student understanding and performance. Initially, assessments were simple tests and quizzes designed to measure a student's grasp of the material. Assessments have changed significantly, from traditional standardized tests to more varied hands-on approaches like project-based learning and digital portfolios. These new methods can be really motivating for students who enjoy showcasing their skills in creative and practical ways. Motivated by their optimism, these students persisted in their hard work, which led to continued success. They emerged as both academic and emotional achievers. (Stiggins, 2005). They get to see how their learning applies to real-world situations, which can be encouraging. However, not all students feel the same way. Some might find these new types of assessments stressful or confusing. Stiggins (2005) stated, "They scored very low on tests, beginning in the earliest grades. The emotional effect was to cause them to question their own capabilities as learners. They began to lose confidence, which, in turn, deprived them of the emotional reserves needed to continue to take risks.” Over time, these evaluations have evolved significantly, especially with technology integration. Integrating digital tools has transformed traditional assessments into more dynamic and interactive experiences, allowing educators to collect real-time data, tailor evaluations to individual needs, and offer immediate feedback. Understanding this evolution is crucial as an educator, especially after the COVID-19 pandemic. The integration of technology into assessments has redefined how we approach student evaluation. It allows for more personalized learning experiences and provides a more comprehensive view of student progress. This is essential for developing effective teaching strategies and ensuring each student receives the support they need. In order to expand my understanding of how to implement and integrate these technological tools in assessments effectively, I will conduct research to learn which tools best fit different learning objectives and how to use data from digital assessments to inform instructional practices, which are areas that require further exploration. Gaining proficiency will increase my ability to evaluate student performance and improve my teaching effectiveness.
Standard-Based Grading vs. Traditional Grade Systems
Image retrieved from: https://www.powerschool.com/blog/everything-you-need-to-know-about-standards-based-grading/
The debate between standard-based grading and traditional grading systems highlights a fundamental shift in assessing student learning. The traditional grade system typically uses letter grades, such as A through F, to evaluate and summarize students' academic performance based on their cumulative scores from tests, assignments, and other assessments. Beachboard and Kersey (2022) state, "A student scans their report card: A in science, Bs in math and history, C in language arts. Receiving an A in science communicates to the student that they are doing well and have reached a level of mastery; the other grades indicate areas to work on. But which parts within language arts, specifically, need work? Traditional grading can leave students and families confused and frustrated, as they give few pointers about which concepts need attention and rarely offer a clear pathway for improvement.” Traditional grading often relies on a cumulative point system derived from averaging assignments, tests, and participation scores.
In contrast, standard-based grading measures student performance against specific learning objectives or standards. Scriffiny (2008) states, "Although many districts adopt standards-based grading in addition to traditional grades, standards-based grading can and should replace traditional point-based grades.” This method aims to provide a clearer picture of what students know and can do rather than how well they perform relative to their peers.
Scriffiny (2008) discusses some of the reasons why standards-based grading is becoming more popular than traditional grading:
Reason 1: Grades Should Have Meaning:
Grades should indicate a student's level of understanding of course objectives. By defining what each letter grade (A, B, C, D, F) shows regarding proficiency in course objectives, educators can provide more meaningful feedback to students, parents, and future teachers.
Reason 2: We Need to Challenge the Status Quo
Traditional grading practices, such as awarding points for homework completion, often need to reflect actual learning. Transitioning to a system where grades are based on mastery of learning objectives ensures that grades accurately reflect students' understanding and encourage meaningful practice.
Reason 3: We Can Control Grading Practices
Teachers can implement grading systems focusing on student understanding rather than peripheral factors like attendance or effort. Standards-based grading allows teachers to provide more accurate assessments of student learning and fosters a more supportive educational environment.
Reason 4: Standards-Based Grading Reduces Meaningless Paperwork
This approach reduces unnecessary paperwork for teachers by assessing student mastery of objectives. This method allows teachers to spend more time on meaningful assessments and providing targeted feedback.
Reason 5: It Helps Teachers Adjust Instruction
Standards-based grading provides more details about students' learning progress, allowing teachers to adjust instruction to address specific learning needs and ensure that both struggling and advanced students receive appropriate support and challenges.
Reason 6: It Teaches What Quality Looks Like
Requiring students to meet specific standards helps students understand and strive for quality work. Separating academic achievement from factors like attendance and behavior teaches students to focus on the quality of their work and develop self-assessment skills.
Reason 7: It is a Launchpad to Other Reforms
Implementing standards-based grading often leads to broader educational reforms, such as more precise curriculum standards and improved formative assessments. This approach promotes better communication with parents and more effective teaching strategies, benefiting all students, including those with special needs and English language learners.
Standard-based grading aligns more closely with modern educational goals, emphasizing content mastery over comparative performance. It allows for more precise feedback on specific skills and knowledge areas, which can be invaluable for students and teachers. I will use the standard-based grading method to explore practical ways to implement this system in the classroom. I need to learn and understand how to design assessments that accurately measure standards and how to communicate these expectations to students and parents, which are critical areas for growth. Mastering these elements will improve my ability to provide meaningful feedback and effectively support student achievement.
TEKS and Teaching
What are the TEKS? According to the Texas Education Agency (TEA), "Texas has adopted curriculum standards for all the state's public schools. The current standards, which outline what students will learn in each course or grade, are called Texas Essential Knowledge and Skills (TEKS). The standards are adopted by the State Board of Education, after extensive input from educators and other stakeholders” (n.d). Incorporating the TEKS framework is vital for ensuring that educational standards are met and that teaching strategies are aligned with state requirements. Assessments are vital in evaluating whether students have mastered the TEKS objectives, providing a basis for instructional decisions and curriculum adjustments. This alignment helps maintain consistency and rigor across different educational settings, ensuring all students achieve the required learning outcomes. For educators, integrating assessments with TEKS is essential for tracking student progress and ensuring instruction focuses on the essential standards. It enables teachers to identify strengths and weaknesses in their teaching methods and adjust their approaches to support student learning better. Using assessments within the TEKS framework ensures that instruction is purposeful and directed toward achieving specific educational goals. To effectively support student learning, teachers must align their assessments with TEKS and engage students actively in the learning process, balancing rigorous academic standards with dynamic, interactive teaching methods to foster understanding and motivation. As a future educator, I need to understand how to create and utilize assessments that align closely with TEKS. Learning more about how to design assessments that accurately reflect TEKS objectives and how to analyze assessment data to inform instruction will be beneficial. This knowledge will help ensure that my teaching practices are effective and that my students meet the expected standards.
Conclusion
Image retrieved from Canva
Assessments are a crucial element of the educational process, evolving from simple tests to complex, technology-enhanced tools that offer deeper insights into student learning. Embracing educational assessment changes is crucial for fostering successful learning outcomes in today's evolving educational landscape. Scriffiny (2008) states, "If your grading system does not guide students toward excellence, it is time for something completely different.” Focusing on mastery of specific learning objectives rather than cumulative scores, educators can offer more targeted feedback and support, addressing individual learning needs and promoting a deeper understanding of the material. Furthermore, aligning assessments with frameworks like TEKS is essential for ensuring that educational standards are met and teaching practices are effective. As educators, staying informed about the latest assessment methods and tools developments is critical to providing students with the best learning experiences. As I continue exploring these evolving assessment practices, I will focus on understanding how to effectively integrate technology, design meaningful assessments aligned with educational standards, and provide actionable feedback that supports student growth. Embracing these changes and continually seeking to improve my understanding will help me support student achievement and foster a more equal and effective educational environment for students.
Resources :
References
Beachboard, C., & Kersey, E. (2022, April 5). Getting started with standards-based grading. Edutopia. https://www.edutopia.org/article/getting-started-standards-based-grading/#:~:text=The%20key%20difference%20between%20traditional,up%20the%20rubric%20to%20mastery.
Edutopia. (2008, July 15). Why is assessment important? https://www.edutopia.org/assessment-guide-importance
Scriffiny, P. L. (2008). Seven Reasons for Standards-Based Grading. Educational Leadership Expecting Excellence, 66(2), 70–74. https://ascd.org/el/articles/seven-reasons-for- standards-based-grading
Stiggins, R. (2005). From Formative Assessment to Assessment for Learning: A Path to Success in Standards-Based Schools. The Phi Delta Kappan, 87(4), 324– 328. http://www.jstor.org/stable/20441998
Texas Education Agency. (n.d.). Curriculum standards. Retrieved July 25, 2024, fromhttps://tea.texas.gov/academics/curriculum-standards
Hello Jessika. "Assessments have long been a foundation of education, serving as the primary method to evaluate student understanding and performance," this is a great observation. For long, assessments were viewed as essential components of teaching. But, now the meaning or results of the tests hold different weight. With the advent of what we call STAAR 2.0, there is need to base our instruction on standard-based grading and not the traditional grading system. I enjoy how you described it as providing a clearer picture of how the students themselves can perform on a standard. With the traditional grading system, it is not always obvious to parents where their child stands on the educational spectrum. But, if we can tie a…
Jessika,
What a fantastic way to not only explain the different assessments educators have access to, but to truly acknowledge that as Scriffiny (2008) states "If your grading system does not guide students toward excellence, it is time for something completely different.” As technology advances so should the grading systems. Times have changed and it's time to embrace new ways of doing things. I particularly appreciated your discussion on the shift from simple tests and quizzes to more varied, hands-on approaches like project-based learning and digital portfolios. Your point about how these new methods can be motivating for some students while potentially stressful for others highlights the complexity of implementing new assessment strategies. It's a crucial reminder that educators, need to…
Jessika,
Your blog “Embracing Change in Educational Assessments for Successful Learning” gave a comprehensive overview of assessment in education and the different approaches of standards-based grading and traditional grading. You give a great background of the how assessments have evolved in education and why they are important. I am a teacher who enjoys project-based learning. I teach my students the skills they need to know and then their assessment is how they use these skills in real world situations. To me, as a Career Technical Education Teacher, this is the best way to assess my students. It is also helpful for students who may have learning difficulties or are English Language Learners.
You used Scriffiny’s seven reasons. I used those…